Singing Potatoes
Tuesday, 13 June 2006
It's a productivity enhancer, really!
Stupid plastic piece of crap!

When I'm listening to music, I can concentrate better on onerous tasks like packing and cleaning the apartment. Both my Palm PDA and my Nokia 770 can play MP3 and Ogg Vorbis files, but I can't put a headphone in the Palm, or it'll shut off the internal speaker for about two weeks, thanks to a nifty short in the jack. And the jack on the 770 is perfectly placed to be as inconvenient as possible in a shirt pocket.

So I went looking for a cheap, small MP3 player. I'd been hoping to pick up another iRiver player, as I like their user interface, but Best Buy no longer carries them (the salesdroid said she thinks they've gone out of business). It looked like SanDisk was making a similar item — roughly equivalent in size and shape — and their 1GB model was $30 cheaper than the 1GB iPod Nano. The only apparent downside was that it took AA batteries. Since I buy AA and AAA batteries in 64-packs, I figured it would be a while before the batteries ate up the price difference.

The interface was truly horrible. While it would let you create a hierarchical file system in its memory, it ignored this entirely when it came time to play the files; you could have them all lumped together in one giant list, or arranged by artist, album or genre. And if the artist name was different in the ID3 tags (for example, "The Calais Consort" vs. "Calais Consort"), it created two different Artist folders. And it would support one solitary playlist, so if you wanted one collection of Renaissance music, regardless of artist or album name, another for humorous Canadian bands, and another for big band swing, well, you were just out of luck. And the font was excessively large for the tiny screen, showing just three files at a time.

Back it went.

I bit the bullet and got me an iPod Nano, marking my first purchase of Apple hardware since my first computer, an Apple ][ (no bloody plus, e, c or lc). And the first thing I did with it was to stick Rockbox on it so it'd play Ogg Vorbis files as well. (I'll admit, I was tempted to put iPodLinux on there instead, but no — it's not stable yet for the Nano. Plus even I think that might be going a little overboard.)

While it's a snazzy little device, I'm sort of regretting that I got the black one; it looks beautiful right up until you touch it and leave fingerprints all over the glassy and mirrored surfaces. That and the fact that there's no anchor point for a lanyard are the only drawbacks I've noticed so far. Oh, there's a third one: if you put the foam covers on the earbuds, they hide the "R" and "L" symbols — but a little red enamel paint on the right one will remedy that easily enough if I decide to stick with the "Mug-Me White" earbuds.

I also got an iPod charger/FM transmitter for the car. Luckily I have an understanding (and pretty) wife who won't begrudge me my last purchase before the move. :-)


Posted by godfrey (link)
Comments
ONE OF US... ONE OF US... And now I can finally send you m4a files, on the day I finally got faac compiled, too!

BTW, don't believe 'em about iPod Linux. It works great on the color 4G iPods--they're just overly cautious over there. If you need an assist, you know where to find me (although the install procedure is probably quite different via PCs than on Macs...) You'll be running movies (and Doom) on your mini in no time!

(5G iPods, like mine, really don't work yet though. Off to check out Rockbox...)
Well, I've got a nano, not a mini — not a whole lot of space on it to begin with, and... oh damn it all, iPodLinux has a port of MAME. Those bastards.

(I meant nano.)

Rockbox requires a FAT32 iPod. Boo!

Don't count out Apple's OS yet, though. And (assuming you're not using it already) iTunes really is a pretty good program. And how can you argue with $9.99 albums? (Well, unless you like the Beatles...)
"my last purchase before the move."

Aha! Now I have it in writing!
iTunes really is a pretty good program.

Don't like it. For starters, I resent having it bundled with the QuickTime installer, so every time I update QuickTime, I have to waste time and bandwidth downloading yet another copy of iTunes (which must remain installed in order to use certain QuickTime codecs).

And iTunes keeps (at least) two processes running on my system at all times, even when it's not in use. I might be better disposed towards it were these things not the case, but I find it really annoying.

Oh yeah, I forgot to add — my nano was already FAT formatted out of the box. I take it other iPods are HFS?

Mac iPods are HFS+, generally.
It's a productivity enhancer, really!
Sometimes, I think you ought to be a politician.
So, is the Luteman Utility Belt full yet? You'll be glad to know Prudish Man has the same affinity for gadgets.
Sometimes, I think you ought to be a politician.

Hey, now! There's no call for that kind of insult.

The utility belt is more than full: Palm, work phone, personal phone, work ID badge and VPN token. The Nokia 770 has to go in a pocket, as does its bluetooth keyboard when I bother to carry it. The iPod will have to go in a pocket too, unless I get one of those armbands or special iPod-compatible sneakers.

Man... I got way too much crap!

Godfrey is the Wyatt Erp of personal computing electronics.